Ugh. Just ugh.
I wrote about hunger last week and how I am learning to tolerate and appreciate real hunger.
And then yesterday I had one of those days where I act like I have no idea what I’m doing or that I’ve learned anything at all in the past five years. You would think after five freaking years of working on my mental control I would be a little bit better at things, but I’ve got news for you: bad days happen.
Yesterday I found myself eating without being hungry physically. I knew I wasn’t hungry and I knew I was trying to fill a void that wasn’t real hunger, but I ate anyway. As I was eating I thought, “I know I’m not hungry, but I don’t want to do anything else. I want to do this. This is okay for now, because I know I’m doing it without being hungry. I’m mad that I’m doing it, but I’m still going to eat this stuff.”
Seriously. That is what I was thinking. I was actively and consciously thinking about why I shouldn’t/didn’t need to be eating, but at the same time I knew I was lonely and trying to fill an emotional void so I did it. And it worked because the carbilicious food made me very tired and I fell asleep to end the miserable day I had ended up creating for myself.
But it just highlighted the point about hunger: PHYSICAL HUNGER is good, but it’s not the reason most of us who ended up being obese ate. At least for me, I rarely ever ate when I was hungry. I spent around eight years gaining weight consistently because I never felt physical hunger, just all kinds of emotional hunger. I always ate to sooth my emotions and to make sure I never had to feel them. I perfected that process.
Old habits die hard. I know I’m not in the same place physically, or emotionally, but I still have days where I revert back to those old habits. Yesterday I may have spent a little bit too much time at my mom’s house. Yesterday I may have not paid attention to my food all day. Yesterday a lot of different things could have contributed to why I did what I did, but for the most part I feel like I did it because I know it is still an option for soothing emotions.
I know that when I want to not feel something I can eat to make it feel better. I am aware that I don’t really want to do this, but apparently on some days it still might happen. And I suppose for now I am okay with that. As long as I don’t do it all the time and I don’t always revert back to that habit then it is okay. Emotional eating is a normal thing, something everyone does from time to time (think: comfort food, food during grieving, etc.).
So for a slip up on one occasion, that is fine. I still feel like even though the old habits and patterns are stored in the back of my mind that I’ve beaten emotional eating. Really, I do. I may have had a bad day, but there could have been multiple bad days since I’ve been home and even more while I was living in Vermont. I didn’t turn to food then. I might have yesterday, but it seems like a rare occurrence and more importantly I was aware of it.
That awareness is important and what separates it from anything I used to do before. I knew what I was doing yesterday. I knew if I wanted to I could stop or didn’t have to eat. I knew I could just go to sleep without eating, but I chose not to. I chose to eat and have a “snack” at night. In the past the choice wasn’t there, because while I was eating to get rid of an emotion it felt like I was out of control and couldn’t even think about what I was doing – I just had to do it. So that is a key difference in this occasion from the past. Even though I ate because of an emotional hunger instead of a physical one, I was aware of it all.
Emotional hunger does exist and often it causes people to eat. I fell into it this time, and I’m big enough to say – it happens. But my new goal for the rest of the year (oh holidays!) is this: ONLY EAT WHEN I AM PHYSICALLY HUNGRY. It is way too easy to fall into the trap of eating for other reasons during this time of year with all the parties and other festivities. I’m not worried so much about what I am eating but only that I am eating when I am hungry. That’s my goal.
I guess I just needed to admit this to someone besides myself. And say… Holidays are frustrating. Honestly. Family can be frustrating. Really. It’s a tough time of year, especially with all the yummy treats sitting around and the emotional turbulence that exists during this time. I love the moments of happiness and joy and family and warmth that do exist, but I’m still ready for this particular season to be over with.
Related posts:


{ 23 comments }
Girl I feel your pain. Emotional Overeating is how I got into the mess of being 100 lbs overweight/obese. And the funny thing is every time I think I’ve conquered this or *get it* find myself mindlessly eating. It’s like a sick psychological trick. Or game. I don’t know what it is or why it happens, but I do know people like us can learn to get over it and work around it. I’ve seen it happen. I’m still in the development phase of that though. The main thing I’ve learned is DON’T BEAT YOURSELF UP. It will make it worse. And stay away from the cookies (okay the last one is one of my rules). I’m sure you’ll be fine, just look forward and have a very Merry Christmas! :)
I know you are new to my blog, but I am way past the point where I beat myself up over anything. I move on so fast you will get whiplash. But when I do something like this I always post about it because it shows people you won’t be perfect when getting to your goals but you don’t need to quit or beat yourself up. Way to many of you peeps out there do that and it just seems very counter productive. So yeah, I don’t do that and I’m really glad you don’t either!
I think I will put myself down for the same goal; it is way too easy to not pay attention to hunger during the holidays, between family encouraging you to try the foods they made (pushed in your face and then set out somewhere for you to stare at), and the stress of being constantly around friends and family without a spare second to ask yourself if you’re hungry at all…
Good luck!
Mal
.-= Mallory´s last blog ..Citrus =-.
I often go through the same exact thought process when I let loose and binge. It’s like, I know I shouldn’t be doing it and I am consciously thinking about it when I am shoving yogurt pretzels in my mouth. I totally get it. You know as well as I do that mistakes will happen, and it’s great that you are blogging about it.
.-= Tony´s last blog ..This Blog =-.
I’m a emotional eater myself too, and I know especially w/ the holidays its going to be hard for me. With teaching I have a 2 wk Christmas break, and b/c I’m single, my mom wants me to be home for a lot of the break. So I’ve settled on a week. It’s going to be a challenge tolerating not only my mother, but also the food that comes along w/ it!
You know, it’s not about being perfect but about learning from our little “detours.” And I love that you always reflect and learn and move forward…
Oh God I know exactly what you’re talking about, I’ve done this honestly multiple times this holiday season. It’s awful. But we just gotta stick with it- there are going to be bad days when we eat for no reason even though we’re aware of it and hate it. On the other hand, there are also going to be days when we listen to our bodies and really do the right thing for ourselves- we just have to make sure that THOSE days are the norm, and not the other way around!
.-= Sagan´s last blog ..Day 22 of the 200 Reps Challenge =-.
I’m really sorry you had a bad day yesterday, but you should feel really proud of yourself for realizing what is really behind what I call “hungry days.” It’s a big deal to come to that realization, and it’s definitely the first step in being able to lessen the number of “hungry days” you experience.
.-= Rachel´s last blog ..Hunger: a gamechanger? =-.
It happens. You get it. Get in a mental space where the turbulence doesn’t affect you as much..if you can.
NZ is around the corner.
:)
~M
.-= Michelle @ Eatingjourney´s last blog ..Change..big scary change! =-.
Oh man, I can relate to this entry. I have been working at this for year’s and still have those days. The cool thing is that you are conscious of what is going on in your head and your emotions. That is a step ahead of many people. The holidays are challenging for sure. I hope you have a very Merry Christmas!
.-= Kat´s last blog ..Hot 100 Challenge – Update #9 =-.
Emotional Eater Here! :) I do find that if I wait til I am REALLY hungry, I binge. It’s a fine line for me.
.-= Lisa´s last blog ..Who wants an invite to my private family site? =-.
I totally get you; in fact I posted about the very same issue yesterday. It’s just weird how you know it’s plain wrong and shouldn’t happen, and yet go on with it.
At least these days I recognize when I’m feeding my emotions; I never used to experience physical hunger because I ate all the time. Then one day a room mate said that she had a headache because she was hungry! I was gobsmacked because I had no idea you could get a headache from hunger – because what is hunger? That was then.
Forgot to type in my web page
.-= Early´s last blog ..Food gone bad =-.
This is why I give myself a calorie cap. I don’t trust any cues from my body.
I have emotional eating down to a science. So I had to make a science out of my eating
I consider it an illness. My eating.
Just like alcohol or drugs, I have no concept of normal or healthy. so I eat like I do bills.
330 calories check
220 calories check
2 fruits check
3 veggies check
good. dinner will be x amount of calories.
If I get hungry later I’ll have a diet coke.
I am a food addict.
Hope you are having a great Christmas.
Hugs
.-= chris´s last blog ..It’s a Wonderful life….Truly. =-.
I can’t count calories. I’m bad at it and it fucks with my mind. So I just eat normally what I want and try to keep the emotional eating out of the picture. It works pretty well most days.
You said it yourself – bad days happen. To all of us!
Here’s to today being a good day!
.-= Hanlie´s last blog ..The role of food in our lives =-.
I’m totally with you. Eating when I’m hungry (ONLY when I’m hungry) is my current challenge too. After letting loose, I always wish I was one of those people who didn’t eat anything in response to stress, instead of eating everything in sight, but wishing doesn’t change anything does it?
Best of luck and I hope you enjoy your holidays!
.-= Heather´s last blog ..141.5 =-.
It is all a learning experience & the fact that we learn, move on & go forward.. that is the important part! WE will have ups & downs all thru life but dealing with them & not letting them deal it to us.. yes!
I have the opposite problem… emotional NOT eating. When I am stressed, sad, angry, in a bad mood… I don’t want to eat. I have learned to recognize this and when I know I should be hungry and I should be eating, I make myself eat anyhow. Like today at lunch. I wasn’t always able to do this, however, and still sometimes let myself go. Eating or not eating, its all the same root problem probably.
.-= merri´s last blog ..Patience and waiting =-.
I’m sorry I didn’t comment on this earlier. I wasn’t sure how to respond.
Bad days happen to all of us. I think, like you said, what was important was you were in control. You made the choice to do it, you can make the choice not to, and you have been :)
I’m glad you shared this with everyone.
We all have our bad days, you just have to fine things that bring you out of the funk that you are in to make you feel better. We all need to stop turning to food to satisfy an emotional need.
Oh Mary – I’m sorry you had a bad day and you knew it/realized it so KUDOS! These days come to all of us, emotional eating – happy, sad, lonely or whatever the emotion, isn’t food (chocolate?!) a comfort?! Got to get out of that in 2010. Over the past 11 months, I’ve lost and maintained 50 lb weight loss. I have tried to keep these “slip ups” in perspective – make it ONE day only and try not to beat myself up after (cause that leads to bigger problems). One step at a time. This will definitely be on my “I WILL” list for 2010. Good luck to you. Like your blog.
Simply Sara – What’s the Skinny?
http://www.whatztheskinny.blogspot.com/
.-= Sara´s last blog ..Wordle it……(click on picture below) =-.
Emotional hunger can really make things difficult, especially when you’re prone to quick weight gain. Life is never easy, but if we start to find solutions in the wrong places, things get much more complicated on the long term.
My solution for this problem would be to focus on the negatives of taking such an action and diverting your mind to something else, immediately. Should work :)
.-= Tina Frey´s last undefined ..(Enjoy 10 returned posts for Christmas) =-.
{ 5 trackbacks }